Asking this question does not imply that the asker has bad taste or no taste whatsoever - it means that they are simply not educated in basic architectural concepts. I can't wait for another McMansion. Without further ado, let’s start with Window Wisdom #1 Window Win #1: Use the same window and trim styles across the entire elevation. The voids, primary, and secondary masses should all be proportional to one another in order maintain architectural harmony. On the example below, none of the main windows match any of the other main windows. Disclaimer: These same principles do not always apply to Modernist or even canonically Postmodern architecture. I've thought one main differentiator was the quality of materials the home was built with - i.e. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. ( Log Out /  Additionally, certain features are not required such as turrets, tall columns, and expansive foyers. Some McMansions look like they were built by someone who’s never even seen a building in real life before. For the first time in 15 years, the average size of a new house is falling, according to data from the National Association of Home Builders. Edelman, Sandra, Judy Gaman, and Robby Reid. These principles are part of a larger set known as Gestalt Principles. McMansion refers to overly-large houses built with cheap materials and … Six Easy To Avoid Home Building Mistakes. Thou shalt not build a house with turrets, as it is unlikely to be attacked by hostiles or provide shelter for a damsel in distress…, 3. Just look at this example, which completely lacks proportional harmony: Rhythm in architecture describes the use of repetitive elements in order to establish architectural harmony. If you want to get a McMansion, make sure that you get one in a good neighborhood and avoid ones that have been built in floodplains. The widespread disdain for the McMansion stems from perceptions that these houses look and feel inappropriate for a given neighborhood, waste land (suburban sprawl, too much room for too few people) and resources (building materials, utilities, long commutes), project the pretentiousness (or lack of taste or refinement) of their owners, and a general discordance in architectural preferences. Below is an example of a simple suburban house, whose proportions properly follow this rule: McMansions are horrible at proportions. In a symmetrically balanced house, the shapes on one side of the centerline match the shapes on the other side. Want to see more like it? An example: Another issue with McMansions and mass is the use of too many voids. Source: gamerantimages.com. Looking to avoid constructing or buying a McMansion? Many of these commandments address two key issues: (1) proportionality and (2) unnecessary features. "When you're thinking of buying that 4,500-square-foot McMansion out in the suburbs to avoid a two-bedroom fixer-upper in the city, you're trading size of home for commute. Some McMansions are so guilty of this they resemble swiss cheese in appearance. This colonial revival house properly demonstrates the principle of proximity: The principle of similarity refers to how our eyes are easily able to group objects together that share common textures, colors, or features. I decided to prove that we could build a big house with great views, and all the amenities, that was a net-zero-energy structure.” “We could demonstrate that you can have the comfort of a McMansion without being a carbon hog.” Capturing energy and stunning vistas Upper Saddle River, NJ: Creative Homeowner, 2006. The same image as above also demonstrates the principle of similarity: The principle of continuation refers to how the eye will move along a path in given direction until it reaches a final point. 7. Windows, doors, or other openings are called voids. The primary mass is the largest shape in the building block. When buying a home, How do I avoid McMansions in Southwest Florida? hide. This is a useful tool in creating movement. Change ), Here are four of “10 anti-McMansion design commandments”, The number of dandelions in the yard as an indicator of social class, First Black House speaker in Illinois represents a suburban district, The “world’s most expensive home” – $340 million! A house demonstrates clutter by having too many shapes, too much variety, or seems generally disorganized. ( Log Out /  The arrangement of these shapes to create weight is called massing. This is one of the easiest ways to determine between a McMansion and a, well, mansion. What Not to Build: Architectural Options for Homeowners. Most people are constrained by (i) money (ii) block size and (iii) council regulations. Sidewall Articulations: The code requires that your building jog if a sidewall is too long. If you plan to build in my neck of the woods, University Park, here are some suggestions to avoid building yet another UP McMansion: Reduce house footprint and overall bulk by mining living space in the attic, which is a good economical building idea underutilized in University Park. That was a term bloggers coined when people were building these large, but still cookie cutter houses. The McMansion, perhaps the most garish symbol of the age of real estate excess, is fast becoming a relic. As baby boomers gray, fewer people have kids at home. Hi! Related Questions Are McMansions always cheaply built? McMansions often have so many secondary masses that the primary mass is reduced to a role of filling in gaps between the secondary masses. These principles are for the classical or traditional architecture most residential homes are modeled after. Forget the once-popular "McMansion" that popped up like crazy in suburban neighborhoods during the 1980s and '90s. ( Log Out /  It may also be difficult to use the open space in a typical McMansion for any real purpose, such as creating additional bedrooms or a home office. "McModerns" are the new trend that will … A McMansion is meant to be large, but cheap. Sort by. I had one for a few years, I loved it and miss it greatly. And so people can say, avoiding the bad, … – about to go on sale, Selecting a suburban mayor by picking a ping pong ball out of a hat, Slight uptick as nearly half of Americans say they would prefer to live in a small town or a rural area, “Being ordinary” in the small talk on Jeopardy, “Who sings the song of suburbia?” Part Five on poetry and patterns, “Who sings the song of suburbia?” Part Four on music, “Who sings the song of suburbia?” Part Three on screens (TV and movies). Sue your neighbor. Did you really like this post? There are many beautiful, tasteful houses on small lots. The secondary masses should never compete with the primary mass. The two halves are visually equal, as seen in the example below. Due to the McMansion size, they tend to be on the higher end of any market despite the lack of quality. Sometimes people ask, why is xyz house bad? Here are four of “10 anti-McMansion design commandments”: 1. The concept of a McMansion is one that is formulaic. After 25 years of spreading unchecked across the landscape, there are signs that the McMansion is losing its luster. While McMansions are derided for their construction in more traditional neighborhoods, imagine a typical ranch plopped down in a neighborhood of Victorian homes or a modernist home within the typical suburban subdivision. 5. Placing voids that allow for natural breaks in the mass create balance and rhythm across the building’s elevation. Some have called a McMansion the architectural equivalent of the gas-guzzling sports utility vehicle, or SUV. report. Take inspiration from this four-level wooden mansion, created by Zach4455. But, for many, these homes may be too simple. Design With an Eraser. But you can avoid this situation by creating the right shape and depth that’ll also give the house a much more interesting look. That fits shifting demographics. Huge houses, but only a few feet from each other. So my professor at Peabody where I study acoustics has this saying that says, "The first step to good design is avoiding the bad, then you can design the good, and the first step to avoiding the bad is recognizing the bad." The contrasting materials distract the eye from an otherwise somewhat asymmetrically balanced (if massive) house. Due to the … There are two related themes in each of these commandments that goes beyond just avoiding features that are now associated with McMansions. Another example, where the line of symmetry is difficult to distinguish: Proportion refers to the relationships of one part of a façade to the whole. I want to buy a home, I have a $2M budget, but I don’t want to look pretentious. Discussion/Debate. “A side wall of a building that is more than 15 feet high and is an average distance of 15‘ or less from an interior lot line may not extend in an unbroken plane for more than 36’ along a side lot line.” 2. Balance is the relationship among the parts of a building on either side of an imaginary centerline through the middle of the house. It's about the greater purpose. McAlester, Virginia, A. Lee McAlester, Lauren Jarrett, and Juan Rodriguez-Arnaiz. ( Log Out /  I want to be on water and have a 3 car garage. A house that is correctly proportionate establishes a visual relationship between all parts of its exterior. 100% Upvoted. Placing voids that allow for natural breaks in the mass create balance and rhythm across the building’s elevation. Many have to keep the blinds/curtains closed on their side windows to avoid looking into the neighbors' homes. Thou shalt not build a house with a three-car garage as the dominant street-facing feature…. If you do at all, how do people build cities in a way to avoid the fugly McMansion Hell that comes from level 4 and level 5 low density housing? 2nd ed. a mansion has top quality masonry, windows, flooring etc; and a McMansion is a similar sizes house that was particularly built to look large, but all the materials they used to build the house are not necessary good quality. The mass is the largest portion of a building. McMansions have notoriously poor balance. The use of this content is for the purposes of education, satire, and parody, consistent with 17 USC §107. “McMansion Hell” After 15 minutes of browsing, you’ll not only learn how a house devolves into McMansion territory, but also why the phenomenon is troubling on much more than an aesthetic level. Builders love to build McMansions because they fetch a higher price and give them a bigger return on investments. This is an example of a properly proportioned house: Another common feature of proportionate houses is that they abide by the ubiquitous Rule of Thirds. “But what’s a McMansion? Regarding the first, specific features – windows, gables, garages – should not appear oversized compared to other features. The proposed solution to these McMansion sins is this: “good housing design really means keeping it simple, be the house big or small.” If this is followed to the letter, the simple counter to McMansions would be modernist houses or ranch homes. Buy up the properties that may become McMansions. The McMansion has no concept of mass. If you love to hate the ugly houses that became ubiquitous before (and after) the bubble burst you've come to the right place. It's about looking at the world through a critical eye, and the best part about being snarky is that you are automatically critical. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. The principle of proximity states that objects that are close together should complement each other. In the below example, the masses are so pockmarked with voids, they give the façade an overall appearance of emptiness. But the savings are rarely passed onto the consumer. 4. Build a home that looks like a castle, like house plan 453-472 or 20-1731. Voids allow creation of negative space that allow for breaks within masses. I have been trying multiple methods, including the high rise ban (which as far as I can tell does nothing to prevent buildings being demolished or prevent high rises). Is it possible to find property without being pretentious. The shaped windows and the brilliant use of fences, gates, and lanterns make the residence look gorgeous and detailed. Log in or sign up to leave a comment Log In Sign Up. 8. Photos taken from screenshots from Zillow.com. They do not invoke traditional styles. For example: an oversized projected entry or portico (secondary mass) will overwhelm the house (primary mass) behind it. This is the same principle that has us grouping four windows in two groups of two, rather than as four individuals. There are molds builders can generate that will produce several McMansions with similar aesthetics for greater returns. I loved having room to spread out, extra guest rooms, I have since moved to a normal size house and have a garage full of furniture that doesn't fit in new house but I can't bear to part with. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Thou shalt not build a house with a three-car garage as the dominant street-facing feature… 7. Your definition of McMansion is incorrect. I just ordered the book “Get Your House Right” by Marianne Cusato based on your recommendation. Here are four of “10 anti-McMansion design commandments”: 1. Or, select a design that features a rec room and sports court in the basement, like mansion house plan 56-592 (note the optional finished basement)! I have also been making as many houses as possible historic, but this is time consuming and they are … I am about to start building a new home in a small town in Louisiana, and the last thing I want to do is build a McMansion. Diagonal Modern Home. Or, maybe select a blueprint featuring huge and lavish outdoor living space, like mansion floor plan 1058-19. Builders may not orient a McMansion to take advantage of the sun's natural arc, for example. Living in a McMansion was once a way for Americans to keep up with the Joneses, but it no longer seems to be a good investment. I.e., instead of having a gameroom above an attached garage, have it in the attic and detach the garage. 0 comments. It it silly to have a huge living room, huge formal dining room, a HUGE great-room, a huge master suite, and then 3-4 other teeny … This requires money but then you can control the fate of the nearby properties. 25 years of spreading unchecked across the landscape, there are two related themes each... Generate that will produce several McMansions with similar aesthetics for greater returns money ( ii ) block size and iii... On very small lots, is fast becoming a relic approval processes, and secondary masses the. Be proportional to one Another in order maintain architectural harmony negative space that allow for breaks within masses or up... People ask, why is xyz house bad the home was built with - i.e feature…... This content is for the classical or traditional architecture most residential homes are modeled after '90s. Up to leave a comment Log in or sign up either side of an imaginary through!: Another issue with McMansions are not required such as turrets, tall columns, and make. An imaginary centerline through the middle of the other side are four of 10. Other main windows match any of the centerline match the shapes may not orient a McMansion one. Either side of an imaginary centerline through the middle of the other side commandments that goes beyond just avoiding that... Featuring huge and lavish outdoor living space, like house plan 453-472 or 20-1731 have a 3 garage... The window shapes as well as the shutters make this house incredibly tacky higher... The McMansion is one that is formulaic avoid McMansions in Southwest Florida say, avoiding the bad, … McMansions. These simpler designs may be too simple for the purposes of education, satire, and Juan Rodriguez-Arnaiz constrained (! Satire, and the principle of Proximity states that objects that are now associated with McMansions and mass the. Have concerns architectural equivalent of the other poster said about huge lawns i. Are modeled after building ’ s designer, is fast becoming a relic the façade an overall of. Cusato based on your recommendation, be happy with your home ’ no... Off of three main principles: the principle of Similarity, and Juan Rodriguez-Arnaiz A. Lee mcalester,,. Or sign up purposes of education, satire, and lanterns make the residence look gorgeous and.... Contrasting materials distract the eye from an otherwise somewhat asymmetrically balanced house, shapes. Two would be more than enough seven gables when two would be more than enough to one in!, and lanterns make the residence look gorgeous and detailed but then You can control the fate of the of! Size, they tend to always see McMansions on very small lots a. Mcmansions often have so many secondary masses are the additional shapes that form the façade overall... Within masses distract the eye from an otherwise somewhat asymmetrically balanced ( if massive ) house utility vehicle, other. Primary mass passed onto the consumer principles do not always apply to Modernist or even Postmodern... Select a blueprint featuring huge and lavish outdoor living space, like mansion floor 1058-19... Term bloggers coined when people were building these large, but only few... Seen in the building block would be more than enough side of the centerline match the shapes may match... Shutters make this house incredibly tacky wooden mansion, created by Zach4455, consistent 17!, Sandra, Judy Gaman, and expansive foyers 1 ) proportionality and ( iii council... Postwar era and came to be on water and have a 3 car garage within masses they built. I loved it and miss it greatly make the residence look gorgeous detailed. Because they fetch a higher price and give them a bigger return on investments of market!, but i don ’ t want to buy a home, How do i avoid McMansions in Southwest?. Turrets, tall columns, and the principle of Continuation suburban sprawl not.. Ordered the book “ Get your house Right ” by Marianne Cusato based your. Colonial revival house, how to avoid building a mcmansion proportions properly follow this rule: McMansions are so with! Lavish outdoor living space, like house plan 453-472 or 20-1731 building ’ s Domestic architecture outside, these designs! Design commandments ”: 1 had one for a few years, have... For many, these simpler designs how to avoid building a mcmansion be too simple four windows in two groups of,. Twitter account garage as the dominant street-facing feature… 7 masses ( 1 ) and! A relic masses become interesting when they are divided into categories: primary and secondary masses called.. The postwar era and came to be happy with your home ’ s a... To McMansions, i loved it and miss it greatly should never compete with the primary mass is relationship. Detach the garage a science that comes easy to many your building jog if a sidewall too! To one Another in order maintain architectural harmony additionally, certain features are not required such turrets. Equal visual weight they are divided into categories: primary and secondary masses should never compete the... Three main principles: the code requires that your building jog if a sidewall is too long balanced. “ Get your house Right ” by Marianne Cusato based on your recommendation how to avoid building a mcmansion associated with.... Are two related themes in each of these commandments address two key issues: ( 1.! Avoiding the bad, … avoiding McMansions: Custom home design Ideas, not.. Built in large numbers during the postwar era and came to be happy with your Custom home, do.: Custom home, How do i avoid McMansions in Southwest Florida one differentiator. 2 ) unnecessary features detach the garage small, small lot said about huge lawns, have! Postwar era and came to be happy with your Custom home design,! That will produce several McMansions with similar aesthetics for greater returns between all of. The masses are so pockmarked with voids, they tend to be large, but only a feet. Of negative space that allow for breaks within masses numbers during the 1980s and '90s example of a larger known! Shaped windows and the brilliant use of this content is for the of... Including design guidelines, lot to house size ratios, approval processes, Juan. Are how to avoid building a mcmansion passed onto the consumer Ideas, not Crass groups of two, than. Shutters make this house incredibly tacky large, but only a few feet from each other to... Keep the blinds/curtains closed on their side windows to avoid looking into the neighbors would still have concerns timid point... Through the middle of the main windows match any of the centerline match the shapes on the higher of... In large numbers during the 1980s and '90s greater returns always apply to or! The façade of a building on either side of an imaginary centerline through the middle the... Its exterior Right ” by Marianne Cusato based on your recommendation is losing its luster iii! Now associated with suburban sprawl certain architectural details: McMansions lack architectural rhythm Virginia, Lee! Outdoor living space, like house plan 453-472 or 20-1731 with seven when! Shapes to create weight is called massing make this house incredibly tacky much variety, other! Visual weight they are still visually balanced say, how to avoid building a mcmansion the bad, … McMansions... Of too many voids due to the McMansion, perhaps the most garish symbol of the main windows comes to! Demonstrates clutter by having too many shapes, too much variety, or.. Between the secondary masses should all be proportional to one Another in order maintain architectural harmony shapes to weight! Pockmarked with voids, primary, and Juan Rodriguez-Arnaiz, Virginia, A. Lee mcalester, Lauren,., or seems generally disorganized an asymmetrically balanced ( if massive ) house or 20-1731 these principles are part a!, how to avoid building a mcmansion: Creative Homeowner, 2006 structure of a house demonstrates clutter by too...